Mascara is a staple in most of our makeup bags, but it's usually limited to two shades: the darkest brown or the blackest back. Not anymore! The colored mascara we once obsessed over in the early 2000s is now back in more richly hued shades than ever. Lately, we've been seeing colored mascaras on the runway and even the latest trending makeup artist videos on social media—but these vibrant mascara shades aren't just for the professionals. You can try this trend for yourself and yes, you can actually pull it off.
If you're ready to bring the fun back into your eye makeup looks, we've got you covered. From luxury brands to your drugstore favorites, check out 3 of the best colored mascaras on the market.
Best for Beginners: MAYBELLINE Great Lash Royal Blue Washable Mascara
This iconic mascara formula is already known for taking lashes to new lengths, so the fact that it now comes in a rich royal blue shade is an added bonus. Hypoallergenic and suitable for contact-wearers, this mascara delivers extra length and volume for a hyped up look. Plus, this blue color adds an understated edge to any eye look, making it a great starter shade for those wary of bright colors.
Best Clump-Free: AVON True Love at 1st Lash Mascara in Velvet Mulberry
No clumps, no smudges—just eye-enhancing color. This mulberry shade delivers a sweet, subtle hue, and while the color may not stand out from several feet away, it complements brown and hazel eyes beautifully.
Pro tip: To get a higher color payoff, let your mascara dry a bit between each coat for better coverage.
Best Mini: FENTY BEAUTY Full Frontal Volume, Lift & Curl Mini Mascara
Don't let the mini size fool you, because this mascara does it all. The longwear, water-resistant formula and flat-to-fat brush deliver volumized and lifted lashes with curl that lasts. It's also buildable with plenty of playtime to layer on the color for a look you'll love. It comes in a rich burgundy shade known as Mi$$ Merlot and a forest green named Ivy League.
